Homeless People Die Young for Want of Housing

December 20, 2012

Tomorrow, December 21, will be the first day of winter. The longest night of the year. And the twenty-second annual National Homeless Persons’ Memorial Day.

Communities around the country will sponsor events to honor homeless men and women who died this year and “to recommit to the task of ending homelessness.”

Here in the District of Columbia — and in some other communities also — there will be a reading of the names of the memorialized homeless. These obviously are people whom local service providers and other concerned community members knew.

But some of the people we’ll commemorate are anonymous. No one knew them well enough to wonder why they were missing — let alone care enough to find out they’d died. In some cases, they’re forever officially nameless.

Many of the named and nameless were probably shockingly young. Homeless people die, on average, nearly 30 years earlier than the rest of us, according to a review of the scant studies we have.

We read occasionally of homeless people freezing to death. Also of homeless people who died because they were violently attacked.

But a much larger percent of the untimely deaths are due to untreated or under-treated illnesses — both communicable diseases like HIV/AIDS and tuberculosis and others more common among the population as a whole, e.g., cancer, diabetes, heart problems and hypertension.

Homelessness itself helps explain those communicable diseases. People in shelters can easily contract them, since they’re bedded down with many others, washing up in communal bathrooms and eating shoulder to shoulder with their co-residents.

Both the sheltered and unsheltered are more susceptible to illness generally because their systems are weakened by lack of rest, hunger and/or unhealthful diets, exposure to extreme temperatures and stress.

All these conditions, of course, also tend to make diseases get worse. When we get  the flu, we stay in bed. Not an option for homeless people who live on the streets or in shelters, which often kick them out at dawn’s early light.

Not surprisingly, homeless people are more likely than others to lack health insurance — even Medicaid. At this point, those who don’t have children and haven’t been certified as severely disabled often aren’t eligible any way.

Fortunately, we have nonprofits that provide free medical care for homeless people — some of it federally funded.

A very high percent of homeless people nevertheless rely on hospital emergency rooms. They presumably get patched up, given in-patient care if needed and discharged, perhaps with a prescription.

But there’s no continuity of care. And both shelter and street living make following a doctor’s instructions difficult.

How, for example, do you store your medications “in a cool, dry place” — and protect them from theft?

How do you faithfully take one pill every four hours or check your blood sugar regularly when you’ve got to keep moving around and trying to rustle up enough money to get something to eat? How do you keep your bandaged wound sterilized?

These questions all assume you understand what you’re supposed to do — and that it’s on your mind, but just too challenging.

Probably not the case for the relatively high, though unknown numbers of homeless people who have a serious mental illness, substance abuse problem or both.*

The message here, which it’s taken me a long time to get to, is that housing is health care, as one of the cosponsors of National Homeless Persons’ Memorial Day says.

And lack of housing can be a death sentence.

If you think this is overwrought, consider what will happen to the AIDS-infected client that attorney Amber Harding at the Washington Legal Clinic for the Homeless tells us about.

Consider what would have happened if he’d gotten the affordable housing he asked for.

* Figures on the rates of these disabilities among homeless people vary widely and many are far from current. The low-end figure for mental illness is 13-15%, but at least double that for homeless individuals classified as chronically homeless.

The U.S. Interagency Council on Homelessness says it’s estimated that nearly half of homeless people suffer from substance abuse disorders.

Right To Shelter In DC Dies On Homeless Persons’ Memorial Day

December 22, 2010

Yesterday, the shortest day of the year, marked the 20th annual National Homeless Persons’ Memorial Day.

Around the country and here in Washington, D.C., public officials, advocates, service providers, homeless people and other community members gathered to commemorate men and women who died while homeless during this hard year.

Let’s also pause to mourn the death of major protections formerly provided by the District’s Homeless Services Reform Act. Because, in an unwitting irony, the DC Council yesterday passed Councilmember Tommy Wells’s amendment to the act for the second time.

This virtually ensures that restrictions which expose homeless people in the District to greater — even life-threatening — risks will become law. And Councilmembers were well aware of the impacts.

Opponents warned that the amendment will be “cruel” to District residents, that we’ll be putting homeless people “who arrive at our doorsteps” out into the cold, that we’ll be “dumbing down” standards for family shelter accommodations.

Reminded their colleagues of someone homeless whose birthday we’re about to celebrate.

All over-ridden by self-congratulatory explanations that homeless people have been flocking here because we’re such a “liberal” jurisdiction.

By recurrent references to the prospective funding shortfall and a potential “over-concentration of facilities” in Ward 4 — a fine justification for letting families freeze if there ever was one.

Plus an assurance that the bill won’t take effect until mid-March, so there’s no danger of “immediate harm” — as if that’s the only kind we should worry about.

“These are difficult times we find ourselves in,” says Council Chairman Vincent Gray as a wrap-up. More difficult than someone comfortably housed can imagine, I think.

Debate notwithstanding, positions were already set in stone. The amendment was a done deal before the vote was taken.

So now what?

Councilmember Wells informs his colleagues that DC General is full, that there’s a long line of families awaiting shelter and that the District “can’t even guarantee a private room” — the new minimum standard for family shelter units.

In other words, the District can’t comply with the weakened law. And there’s not a shred of evidence that the problematic proof-of-residency requirements (see here and here) will make much difference.

No difference at all to the homeless families that can’t get into DC General because the Council failed to ensure that the Department of Human Services could in fact cope with needs for shelter beyond the dubious projections in this year’s winter plan.


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 232 other followers