What Will Jobless Workers Do Now?

Wonkblogger Brad Plumer teed up this question in response to the imminent expiration of the Emergency Unemployment Compensation program.

As I (and many others) have written, 1.3 million jobless workers will lose their federally-funded unemployment insurance benefits on December 28, unless Congress renews the program.

By a year from now, about 3.5 million more will have had no EUC to turn to when they’ve searched, without luck, for work longer than their regular state UI program covers.

House Speaker John Boehner has seized on the latest jobs report as a new reason to shrug off “calls for more emergency government ‘stimulus,'” understood by one and all as a reference to the EUC program.

House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi has said that Democrats won’t vote for a budget deal without the EUC extension, though it wouldn’t have to be in the budget bill itself.

But as Washington Post blogger Greg Sargent observed, the Democrats might back down rather than vote against a bill that offers some sequestration relief. For most, that now seems a virtual certainty, as Pelosi’s response to the deal suggests.

Not to detract from the potential immediate crisis, but Plumer’s question raises a broader issue. What will long-term jobless workers do when their UI benefits expire, as they will for some even if Congress extends the EUC program.

As Plumer indicates in a followup post, we can be pretty certain that most of the workers who lose their UI benefits won’t try to use SSDI (Social Security Disability Insurance) as a safety net, notwithstanding debunked reports to the contrary.

They may just drop out of the labor force, Plumer says. Robert Oak at The Economic Populist reports that more than 3.1 million did over the course of the last year alone.

What happens to them then?

If they’re in their early 60s, like one of the “real people” ThinkProgress editor Bryce Covert profiles, they may apply for early Social Security retirement benefits.

They’ll receive less than they would if they waited until they reached full retirement age — and perhaps less than they received from the EUC program, as would be the case 62-year-old Covert interviewed. But they may have no choice, given the barriers older job-seekers face.

They’re a relatively small portion of the unemployed workers the Bureau of Labor Statistics counts, however. Uncounted, for all age groups, are those who haven’t recently looked for work. There are more than 5.6 million of them, according to the Economic Policy Institute’s latest estimate.

Surely some stopped looking when their UI benefits ran out. Not before, of course, because you’ve got to be actively looking to get them. Yet we know the job search gets increasingly futile.

Some employers, it seems, won’t even consider someone who’s been out of work for more than six months. That’s less time than most states’ regular UI programs cover.

Time was when there was some interest in the really long-term unemployed — the 99ers, so called because the combination of state and federal UI benefits provided 99 weeks of coverage in states with the highest unemployment rates.

Now they’re invisible, Daily Kos blogger Bud Meyers says. By and large, I think this is true.

But New York Times reporter Annie Lowrey recently told the painful story of a woman who’s now “broke and homeless” because she hasn’t been able to find any job at all since she was laid off from a mid-level position in 2008.

A veteran Lowrey also interviewed hasn’t had a job since he came back from Iraq in 2007. “I’m just trying to hang on until my retirement kicks in,” he says. But he’s only 57.

Economists Dean Baker and Kevin Hassett — not a pair you’d ordinarily expect to find co-authoring an op-ed — call the persistent high rate of long-term unemployment “a national emergency.”

They run through research findings indicating a range of human costs, e.g., a higher male mortality rate (due partly to suicides), serious illnesses, divorces, an impact on what children in the family will ultimately earn.

A recent report by the Urban Institute and First Focus identifies a variety of harms to children that can account for the lower earnings — most, if not all of them related to family income loss.

To poverty, in fact, since the poverty rate for parents who’ve been unemployed for more than six months nearly triples, even when the value of safety net benefits is counted as income.

There’s no dearth of sensible ideas for what our government could do to address the long-term unemployment crisis. Baker and Hassett itemize a whole policy package.

I’ve seen many others. Most, if not all reflect a consensus on some measures, e.g., subsidized employment, direct government hiring, larger (and better) training programs.

All these would, of course, be good for the economy — more consumer spending, so more jobs created, even beyond those the government itself might fund. There’d thus be more tax revenues as well.

But it’s the “human disaster” flagged in the Baker-Hassett headline that concerns me here.

When people drop out of the labor force, they don’t drop off the face of the earth. Our failure to avert the damages so many have already suffered is, to my mind, a shame, since the single largest reason is our federal government’s short-sighted focus on reducing spending.

At the very least, Congress can act immediately to extend a lifeline to the long-term — but not longest-term — jobless workers who haven’t dropped out.

But it also ought to do something to help them — and the rest — find gainful work again.


6 Responses to What Will Jobless Workers Do Now?

  1. zoom314 says:

    Republicans in Congress won’t lift a finger to do so, I think they believe in Social Darwinism or ‘survival of the fittest’, and so they simply do not care, but then these people are of the Rich and are out of touch and out to lunch…

    People will need to VOTE as many Repubs out of office on Tuesday NOvember 4th, 2014 to fix the USA…

  2. I totally agree. I wonder how many republicans that are loosing their benefits and will still vote for a republicans at the polls. I just can not understand the stupidity

  3. Kathryn Baer says:

    I too have been struck by how many people who are negatively affected by conservatives’ “austerity” policies seem to vote against their self-interest. I’ve been trying to figure out why.

  4. trevormaat says:

    This focus on austerity is extremely short sighted as you say. Most of these programs facing cuts were put into place for times like this: following extreme economic calamities. Nothing is more sad than reading the comment sections of news articles about income, employment, and education inequalities. People who argue for the policies that promote inequality don’t seem to understand how it hurts and impacts them. It’s insane. Great piece btw.

  5. nilknarf1940 says:

    Reblogged this on TMO Alief and commented:
    Poverty continues to grow with no end or solution in sight.

  6. missdisplaced says:

    I can tell you what happens. It happened to me a few years ago when my benefits ran out.

    1. You go on welfare programs (if available).
    2. You may become homeless.
    3. If you’re lucky, you may move in with family, if not lucky the street.
    4. Live out of your car.
    5. You become a drug dealer or steal to survive.

    I’ve known a people who were forced into these situations because they simply could not find a job… any job! Once you do become “homeless” it becomes even more impossible to obtain work.

    The people I have known were not bad people. Nor did they have anything to prohibit them from obtaining employment (such as a criminal record). They were educated, had skills (construction, retail, machinist, computer, etc.) and STILL could not get hired.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s